High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Jasim Uddin v Kazi Amir Uddin and others
Civil Revision 2814/2023 · Decided 4 March 2026
The pre-emptor, a co-sharer of the holding, sought pre-emption (a co-sharer's right to buy land sold to an outsider) of land sold to a stranger to the holding by a deed dated 12.11.2007. He claimed he learned of the sale on 25.11.2007, confirmed it on 26.11.2007 with a certified copy, and filed on 21.01.2008. The trial court dismissed the case as time-barred and the appellate court affirmed. No one appeared for the pre-emptor in revision. The High Court Division found that the pre-emptor himself admitted the purchaser took possession immediately after the purchase, and the purchaser built a house on the land, so the sale was known from its inception. The two months therefore ran from 12.11.2007 to 11.01.2008, and the case was 10 days late. A statutory right of pre-emption must be sought within the limitation period. As the appellate court, the final court of fact, had properly considered the evidence, there was no ground to interfere. The Rule was discharged without costs.
Rule discharged; dismissal of pre-emption suit upheld
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Pre-emption (ogrokroy)The right of a co-sharer to take over a share of jointly held land sold to an outsider, by applying to court and depositing the price plus compensation.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the pre-emption case was filed within the two-month limitation period, given that the purchaser took possession immediately after the sale.
- Q2
Whether the High Court Division in revision could interfere with the concurrent findings of the courts below that the pre-emptor knew of the sale from its date.
- The courts below rightly found that the pre-emptor had knowledge of the sale from the date of purchase, 12.11.2007, as he admitted the purchaser took possession immediately, and witnesses and the Advocate Commissioner showed the purchaser had built a dwelling house on the land.
- The pre-emption case had to be filed within two months from 12.11.2007, that is by 11.01.2008, and filing on 21.01.2008 was 10 days beyond the statutory period.
- Although pre-emption is a statutory right, it must be sought within the prescribed time, and courts must strictly apply limitation where the sale was within the pre-emptor's knowledge.
- Following Hazari Bala Sana v Niron, 17 BLD (AD) 294, findings of fact by the lower appellate court bind the High Court Division in revision save for misreading or non-consideration of material evidence, none of which was shown.
- The Rule was discharged without costs and the dismissal of the pre-emption case upheld.
The right of pre-emption though a statutory right of pre-emptor, at the same time it must be sought within the prescribed time of limitation.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 2814/2023, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 12 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1In the Supreme Court of Bangladesh
2High Court Division
3(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice Md. Mansur Alam
6CIVIL REVISION NO. 2814 of 2023
7Md.Jasim Uddin
8Pre-emptor-appellant-petitioner
9Versus
10Kazi Amir Uddin being dead his
11heirs are:-1.Kalan Begum and others
12Pre-emptee-respondents-opposite parties
13No one appear
14for the petitioner
15Mr. Mohammad Jaynal Abedeen Bhuiyan,
16Advocate
17for the opposite party
18Heard on:12.01.2026 & 18.02.2026
19Judgment on: 04.03.2026.
201.This Rule was issued calling upon the opposite party Nos.1-4 to show cause as to why the impugned judgment and order dated 07.02.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 2nd Court, Brahmanbaria in Miscellaneous Appeal No.16 of 2017 dismissing the appeal and thereby affirming the judgment and order dated 28.02.2017 passed by the learned
Senior Assistant Judge, Nasirnagor, Brahmanbaria in Miscellaneous Preemption Suit No.06 of 2008 should not be set aside, and/or pass such other or further order or orders passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
212.The short facts of the case of the pre-emptor-appellant-petitioner is that 56 decimals of land including the suit land was recorded in the BS khatian No.689 in Md. Hakim Uddin, the predecessor of the plaintiff and opposite party Nos.2-6. After the death Md. Hakim Uddin by way of mutual family settlement of the plaintiff-petitioner was in possession of the portion of land and the opposite party Nos.2 and 3 without letting anything to know to the plaintiff-petitioner transferred 56 decimals of land from plot no.470 and 471 to opposite party No.1. This sale was beyond the knowledge of the plaintiff-petitioner, thereafter the plaintiff-petitioner came to know about
the sale on 25.11.2007 and being confirmed about the sale on 26.11.2007 after obtaining the certified copy of the sale deed. The plaintiff-petitioner thereafter filed the pre-emption suit.
223.On the other hand plaintiffrespondent-opposite party entering appearance of the suit and by filling written objection contending inter alia that opposite party Nos.2 and 3 after inheritance the suit land obtaining mutation khatian No.729 transferred the suit land to the opposite party No.1.
23The suit land measuring .15 decimals of plot No.471 was recorded in B.S. khatian No.379 in the name of Zohora Khatun the plaintiff-petitioner was not tenant in the disputed jote (khatian). The preemption petition is barred by limitation and defect of parties.
244.On trial the learned Senior Assistant Judge, after hearing both the parties dismissed the pre-emption suit No.06 of 2008 dated 28.02.2017 and thereafter the
pre-emptor-petitioner preferred appeal before the appellate Court and the appellate Court disallowed the appeal on 07.02.2023.
255.Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment of the appellate Court the pre-emptorpetitioner moved this revision petition.
266.No one appear for the petitioner. Learned Advocate for the pre-emptorpetitioner did not come before this division as the time of hearing.
277.On the other hand Learned Advocate appearing for the respondent-opposite party takes me in course of argument through the plaint, written statement, the judgment of the trial Court and that of the appellate Court and the evidence and materials on record and then submits that the pre-emptor-petitioner has failed to prove that the petition was filed within the period of statutory period of limitation, learned appellate Court as well as trial Court on scrutiny
of the evidence and on appreciation of the materials on record rightly found that the pre-emptor-petitioner was quite aware about the transaction of the deed and about the possession of the opposite party No.1. So, the learned Court below rightly disallowed the pre-emption petition.
288.Having heard the learned Advocate appearing for the pre-emptee-respondentopposite party and having considered the evidence and material on record.
299.It appears to be proved that the opposite party no 1, purchaser of the pre-emption deed is a stranger in the alleged holding. On the other hand the pre-emptor Jasimuddin is a co-sharer of the alleged suit jot. Learned trial court and Learned Appellate court are concurrently found that the pre-emption suit is barred by limitation. Both the Court found no other defects in the preemption suit.
3010.Now it is to be determined whether the suit is instituted within the statutory period of time or the same is instituted on expiry of that period.
3111.The suit was transferred to the opposite no.1 on 12.11.2007 by way of kabala deed no.5580. The–emptor came to know about the alleged sale on 25.11.2007 and became confirmed about that sale on 26.11.2007 on obtaining the certified copy of the sale deed. Thereafter he filed the present preemption case on 21.01.2008.
3212.This contention of the pre-emptor is strongly opposed by the opposite party.
33The opposite party’s specific case in this context is that the pre-emptor was aware of the alleged deed, delivery of possession and the transaction thereof from the date of the sale. The preemptor himself admitted in his testimony that the pre-emptee went in possession in the suit land from the date of purchase. The pre-emptee-opposite party
claimed that he erected a dwelling house on the suit land by cutting soil. Two witnesses were testified in supporting the possession of the opposite party in the aforesaid manner. Advocate Commissioner also found the dwelling house of the opposite party built by cutting soil in the suit land. The preemptor admitted that the opposite party went in possession in the suit land immediately after the purchase. So it is proved that the opposite party was in possession from 12.11.2007. In this circumstances where the manner of the possession is very much manifest, so the pre-emptor as well as all other neighbour are very much aware regarding the sale and possession of the suit land from its inception.
3413.Learned Appellate Court and the trial Court on appreciation of the evidences concurrently found that the pre-emptor has failed to prove his contention that he came to know first on 25.11.2007 and
thereafter on 26.11.2007 obtaining the certified copy of the alleged preemption deed. Both the Court below concurrently found that the pre-emptor had knowledge about the alleged sale from the date of purchase i.e. from 12.11.2007. The pre-emptor is to file the pre-emption case within two months from 12.11.2007 which in calculation stands till the date of 11.01.2008. But the pre-emptor filed the present suit on 21.01.2008 expiring the statutory period of limitation of 10 days. The right of pre-emption though a statutory right of pre-emptor, at the same time it must be sought within the prescribed time of limitation. The pre-emptor lost his preemption right since he failed to substantiate his right within the statutory period of time.
3514.In this aspect some principles with regards to the pre-emption limitation is considered to be discussed here:-
361. Pre-emption suits must be filed within the specified period of two months from the date of knowledge or registration.
372. If a pre-emptor claims a later date of knowledge to bypass limitation, the courts will examine evidence to determine if the claim is valid or a fabrication.
383. The Appellate Division often uphold lower court findings that a preemption case is time-barred when both lower courts have specifically observed that the sale was within the pre-emptors knowledge.
394. If it is proved that notice under the relevant Act was not served or was a subsequent, fraudulent creation, the limitation period may not begin until actual knowledge is established.
405. A pre-emptor who waives their right or fails to act promptly may lose their case, as seen in decisions affirming
that long delay or acquiescence can defeat the right of pre-emption.
41On analyzing the above principles it can be concluded that Court is to strictly follow the limitation matters and beyond the period of limitation, no pre-emption would allow when the sale is made within the knowledge of the pre-emptor.
4215.It is a settled principle of law that the findings of fact arrived at by the lower Appellate Court which is the final court of fact is binding on the High Court Division as revisional Court except in certain well-defined exceptional circumstances, such as nonconsideration or misreading of the material evidence affecting the merit of the case. But in this case it appears that Learned Appellate Court carefully considered all the material facts and circumstances of the case and evidence on record in arriving at its findings.
43More so the Learned Advocate for the
petitioner did not turn up before the Court to substantiate his contention in this regard. As such in revisional jurisdiction there is no scope to interfere with the judgment and decree of the appellate Court. This principle is well discussed in the case of Hazari Bala Sana Vs. Niron reported in 17 BLD (AD) 1997 at page 294.
4416.In view of the discussion made as above, this division finds that learned both the Court below was quite justified in dismissing the pre-emption petition.
45This division find no misreading, misinterpreting or non consideration of evidence by the Appellate Court. In this facts and circumstances the impugned judgment of learned Appellate Court warrants no interference.
4617.In the result the Rule is discharged without any order as to costs.
4718.The impugned judgment and order dated 07.02.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 2nd Court,
48Brahmanbaria in Miscellaneous Appeal
49No.16 of 2017 dismissing the appeal and
50thereby affirming the judgment and order
51dated 28.02.2017 passed by the learned
52Senior Assistant Judge, Nasirnagor,
53Brahmanbaria in Miscellaneous Pre-
54emption Suit No.06 of 2008 dismissing
55the suit is hereby upheld and confirmed.
5619.Send down the lower Courts’ record
57with a copy of this Judgment to the
58Courts’ below at once.
59Hasan.A.B.O
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











