High Court Division · Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Md. Habibur Rahman Nannu v Md. Abdul Gafur and others
Civil Revision 809/2021 · Decided 13 July 2023
The opposite parties, as plaintiffs, won an eviction decree against the petitioner, a defaulter tenant, in the Small Causes Court (a special summary court for small civil disputes) on 02.03.2011. His civil revision in the High Court Division was rejected, and the Appellate Division rejected his civil petition for leave to appeal. When the plaintiffs sought to execute the decree, he asked the executing court to stay execution under Order XXI rule 29 until his Title Suit No. 90 of 2020 and two other suits were decided. The executing court refused, and the Senior District Judge, Jamalpur, upheld that refusal. The High Court Division discharged the Rule. It held the decree had merged in the Appellate Division's order and could not be challenged in a civil court by a party who took part in it. It directed that execution be concluded within three months, and that the plaint of Title Suit No. 90 of 2020 be rejected with exemplary costs.
Rule discharged; execution to proceed; plaint to be rejected
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- Arji (plaint)The arji, or plaint, is the written claim that starts a civil suit, setting out the parties, facts, cause of action, valuation and the relief the plaintiff asks for.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether execution of a Small Causes Court eviction decree could be stayed under Order XXI rule 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure pending a later title suit challenging that decree.
- Q2
Whether a party who took part in Small Causes Court proceedings could challenge the decree in a civil court after it was upheld up to the Appellate Division.
- The Small Causes Court decree merged in the Appellate Division's order rejecting the petitioner's civil petition for leave to appeal.
- The petitioner could not show that he was a party to Partition Suit No. 160 of 2010, and the Appellate Division had finally found him a defaulter tenant who had to hand over vacant possession first.
- The judgment and decree of a Small Causes Court cannot be challenged in a civil court by a party who participated in those proceedings.
- Filing Title Suit No. 90 of 2020 after the Appellate Division's decision was unlawful and challenged the supremacy of the Supreme Court.
- The Rule was discharged, and the Senior Assistant Judge was directed to conclude the execution case within three months and to reject the plaint of Title Suit No. 90 of 2020 with exemplary costs.
The judgment and decree of a suit of the Small Causes Court cannot be challenged in a Civil Court by a party who participated in the above S.S.C. proceedings.
In the court’s own words.
Civil Revision 809/2021, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 8 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
1IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
2HIGH COURT DIVISION
3(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
4Present:
5Mr. Justice S M Kuddus Zaman
6CIVIL REVISION NO.809 OF 2021
7In the matter of:
8An application under Section 115(4) of the Code of Civil
9Procedure.
10And
11Md. Habibur Rahman Nannu
12…. Petitioner
13-Versus-
14Md. Abdul Gafur and others
15…. Opposite parties
16Mr. Kamal Hossain, Advocate
17…. For the petitioner.
18Mr. Md. Mahabubur Rashid, Advocate
19…. For the opposite party Nos.1
20and 3-7.
21Heard and Judgment on 13.07.2023
22On an application under Section 115(4) of the Code of Civil Procedure this Rule was issued calling upon the opposite Nos.1-7 to show cause as to why the impugned judgment and order dated 04.02.2021 passed by the learned Senior District Judge, Jamalpur in Civil Revision No.2 of 2021 dismissing the revision and thereby affirming the order dated 06.12.2020 passed by the learned Senior Assistant Judge, 1st Court, and S.C.C. Judge, Jamalpur in S.C.C. Execution Case No.3 of 2011 arising out of S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 rejecting the application filed by the defendant-petitioner for staying all further proceedings of the Execution Case under Order 21 Rule 29 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
23Facts in short are that the petitioner who is the judgment debtor of Decree Execution Case No.3 of 2011 submitted a petition before the Executing Court under Order 21 Rule 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure for staying the proceedings of above execution case till disposal of Other Class Suit No.90 of 2020 filed by the petitioner as plaintiff challenging the legality and propriety of the judgment and decree and passed on 02.03.2011 in S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 which was under execution in above case.
24It was alleged that after passing of above judgment and decree in S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 against the petitioner who was the defendant in above suit by the Small Causes Court the petitioner as plaintiff has filed Title Suit No.90 of 2020 for a decree declaring that above judgment and decree of the Small Causes Court is unlawful and not binding upon the plaintiffs.
25It was further stated that for the disputed premises the opposite party has further filed Suit No.160 of 2010 for partition and Land Survey Tribunal Suit No.2418 of 2014 against erroneous record of the disputed premise in the names of the opposite party. As such execution of above decree should be stayed till disposal of above three suits filed by the petitioner.
26On consideration of submissions of the learned Advocates for the respective parties and materials on record the learned Judge of the
Small Causes Court rejected above petition vide impugned judgment and order dated 06.12.2020.
27Being aggrieved by above judgment and order the opposite party as petitioner preferred Civil Revision No.2 of 2021 before the learned Senior District Judge, Jamalpur who on consideration of the submissions of the learned Advocates for the respective parties and materials on record rejected above Civil Revision and affirmed the judgment and order of the Small Causes Court.
28Being aggrieved by above judgment and order of the learned Senior District Judge above petitioner as petitioner moved to this Court and obtained this Rule.
29Mr. Kamal Hossain, learned Advocate for the petitioner submits that opposite parties as plaintiffs instituted S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 for eviction of the defendant-petitioner who was the tenant of the disputed premises and above suit was decreed on contest on 02.03.2011. Being aggrieved by above judgment and decree of the Small Causes Court the petitioner preferred Civil Revision No.1872 of 2011 to the High Court Division but the Rule was discharged on 29.09.2014. Challenging the legality and propriety of above judgment and order of the High Court Division the petitioner preferred Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.3014 of 2014 to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh which was rejected on 21.01.2017. Thereafter challenging the legality and propriety of above judgment and decree dated
02.03.2011 passed in S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 the petitioner has filed Title Suit No.90 of 2020 and the same is pending for trial. The petitioner has also filed a suit for partition being Partition Suit No.160 of 2010 and Land Survey Tribunal Suit No.2418 of 2014 in the Land Survey Tribunal which are also pending for trial. As such the petitioner filed above petition for stay of the proceedings of S.C.C. Execution Case No.3 of 2011. But the learned the learned Judge of the Small Causes Court has most illegally rejected above petition and the learned District Judge without an independent assessment of the materials on record most illegally dismissed the Civil Revision and affirmed above flawed judgment and order of the Execution Court which is not tenable in law.
30On the other hand Mr. Md. Mahabubur Rashid, learned Advocate for the opposite party Nos.1 and 3-7 submits that the opposite parties as plaintiffs instituted S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 for eviction of the petitioner who was a tenant of the opposite parties from the disputed premises and the suit was decreed on contest on 02.03.2011. Above judgment and decree was affirmed by the Appellate Division by rejection of Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal filed by the petitioner. Opposite parties filed S.C.C. Execution Case No.3 of 2011 for executing above decree of S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998. But the petitioner has filed Title Suit No.90 of 2020 in the Court of Senior Assistant Judge challenging the judgment and decree of the S.S.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 which was decreed against him on contest and which was finally affirmed by the Appellate
Division in the judgment and order passed in Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.3014 of 2014 which is unlawful and not tenable in law.
31I have considered the submissions of the learned Advocates for respective parties and carefully examined all materials on record.
32It is admitted that the opposite party Nos.1-7 as plaintiffs filed S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 for eviction of the petitioner who was the sole defendant claiming that he was a defaulter tenant of the disputed premise and above suit was decreed on contest on 02.03.2011 and the petitioner preferred Civil Revision No.1872 of 2011 to the High Court Division challenging the legality and propriety of above judgment and decree of S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 which was rejected vide judgment and order dated 29.09.2014.
33It is also admitted that the petitioner challenging above judgment and order of the High Court Division passed in Civil Revision No.1872 of 2011 preferred Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.3014 of 2014 to the Appellate Division which was rejected on 08.05.2017.
34As such the judgment and decree passed by the S.C.C. Court in S.C.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 was merged in the judgment and order of Appellate Division passed in Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.3014 of 2014.
35The learned Advocate for the petitioner could not substantiate his claim that the petitioner is at all a party to the Partition Suit No.160 of 2010. Undisputedly the suit premise was recorded in the name of the
opposite party. Since the petitioner was found a defaulter tenant of the opposite party finally by the Apex Court of the Court, the Appellate Division he was legally bound to handover over vacant possession to the opposite party before raising any new claim over the disputed premises.
36The proceedings of Small Causes Court is a special and summary proceedings for expeditious disposal of small civil disputes and no appeal lies from the judgment and decree passed by a Small Causes Court.
37Petitioner who was the sole defendant of S.S.C. Suit No.8 of 1998 and he contested above suit. The petitioner challenged the legality and propriety of the above judgment and decree of S.C.C. Suit No.08 of 1998 both to the High Court Division and to the Appellate Division by preferring Civil Revision No.1872 of 2011 and CPLA No.3024 of 2014 but of no avail. The Appellate Division has finally determined that the petitioner is a defaulter tenant of the disputed premises under the opposite parties.
38But instead of abiding by above final and conclusive determination made by the Apex Court of the country and voluntarily handing over the vacant possession to the opposite party the petitioner filed above mentioned Title Suit No.90 of 2020 after about three years of above judgment and order of the Appellate Division.
39The judgment and decree of a suit of the Small Causes Court cannot be challenged in a Civil Court by a party who participated in the above S.S.C. proceedings.
40The petitioner has in fact challenged the authority and supremacy of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh, the Apex Court of this country by filing above mentioned Title Suit No.90 of 2020 in the Court of Senior Assistant Judge. This is not only unlawful it is highly contemptuous as well. It is not understandable as to how an Advocate could prepare and present such a plaint which promotes the creation of judicial anarchy. The Senior Assistant Judge of Jamalpur should have rejected the plaint outright at the time of the presentation of the same and also imposed cost upon the plaintiff. If Title Suit No.90 of 2020 remaining alive and pending for hearing the proceedings of Execution Case No.2 of 2011 will be further delayed and the confidence of the people is our judicial system will continue to decline.
41In above view of the materials on record I am unable to find any substance in this Civil Revision and the Rule issued in this connection is liable to be discharged.
42In the result, the Rule is discharged.
43The learned Senior Assistant Judge is directed to conclude the proceedings of Decree Execution Case No.3 of 2011 within 3(three) months from the date of receipt of this order without any fail.
44The learned Senior Assistant Judge, Jamalpur is further directed to reject the plaint of Title Suit No.90 of 2020 forthwith after receipt of a copy of this order and also impose an exemplary cost upon the plaintiffs for filling about suit.
45Communicate the judgment and order to the Senior Assistant Judge, Jamalpur at once.
46Send down the lower Court’s records immediately. MD. MASUDUR RAHMAN BENCH OFFICER
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











