High Court Division · Special Original Jurisdiction
Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Chattogram v Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal and another
Writ Petition 10279/2025 · Decided 20 May 2026
Maddhapara Granite Mining Company Limited imported prilled ammonium nitrate declared under H.S. Code 3102.30.00. Customs found that the correct code was 2834.29.90 and treated the declaration as a breach of section 32 of the Customs Act, 1969. On summary adjudication the Commissioner of Customs, Chattogram demanded additional duty and imposed a penalty of Tk. 43,00,000 and a redemption fine. The Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal partly allowed the importer's appeal, set aside the penalty and fine, and relied on an NBR letter stating that a later change of an H.S. Code previously accepted for the same goods should not be treated as misdeclaration. The Commissioner filed a writ petition, saying the appeal period under section 196D had passed while government permission was sought. The High Court Division found no illegality in the Tribunal's order and held that, since such orders are appealable under section 196D and no breach of fundamental rights, mala fides or want of jurisdiction was shown, the writ petition was not maintainable.
Rule discharged as not maintainable
- Rule absolute and Rule dischargedThe two final results of a Rule in the High Court Division: made absolute means the petitioner wins; discharged means the petition fails and the order below stands.Read the full explanation →
- MaintainabilityWhether a case can lawfully be heard at all, before its merits: the right court, the right person, filed in time and not barred by any law.Read the full explanation →
- Q1
Whether the Commissioner of Customs may challenge an order of the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal by writ petition instead of the statutory appeal under section 196D of the Customs Act, 1969.
- When a question of maintainability is raised in a writ petition, the court's first duty is to decide whether the petition is maintainable.
- An order of the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal under section 196B of the Customs Act, 1969 is appealable to the High Court Division under section 196D.
- Where an appeal lies under section 196D and the petitioner shows no violation of fundamental rights, mala fides, colourable exercise of power or lack of jurisdiction, a writ petition against the Tribunal's order is not maintainable.
- The court found no illegality in the Tribunal's order setting aside the penalty and redemption fine in view of the NBR letter on changes to previously accepted H.S. Codes and the earlier clearance of identical goods under the declared code.
On consideration of the above provision, it is evident that any order passed by the Tribunal under section 196B of the Act, 1969 is an appealable order under the section 196D of the Act, 1969.
In the court’s own words.
Writ Petition 10279/2025, as published by the Supreme Court of Bangladesh. 9 pages, with paragraph numbers for citing.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
WRIT PETITION NO. 10279 OF 2025
IN THE MATTER OF:
An application under Article 102(2)(a)(ii) of the
Constitution of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh.
And
IN THE MATTER OF:
Commissioner of Customs, Customs House,
Chattogram
…. Petitioner
-Vs-
Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal
and another.
….Respondents.
Mr. Akhtar Farhad Zaman, Deputy Attorney
General with Ms. Shadia Afrin Shapla, Deputy
Attorney General with Mr. Arif Khan, Deputy
Attorney General with Mr. Sovan Mahmud, Mr.
Md. Faridul Islam and Mr. Md. Nazmul Haque,
Assistant Attorney Generals
…For the petitioner
Mr. Mohammad Jamal Hossain, Advocate
… For the respondent No.2
Heard on 17.05.2026,18.05.2026
Judgment on 20.05.2026.
Present:
Mr. Justice S.M. Maniruzzaman
and
Mr. Justice Dihider Masum Kabir
S.M. Maniruzzaman, J:
1In this Rule Nisi, issued under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, the respondents have been called upon to
show cause as to why the impugned order dated 20.02.2024 passed by respondent No. 1, the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal, in CEVT Case (Cus) No. 535/2023 (Annexure-A), setting aside the order dated 11.07.2023 passed by the Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Chattogram, should not be declared to have been passed without lawful authority and is of no legal effect, and/or why such other or further order or orders should not be passed as to this Court may seem fit and proper.
2At the time of issuance of the Rule, further operation of the order dated 20.02.2024(Annexure-A) was stayed by this Court for a prescribed period.
3Facts, relevant for disposal of the Rule, in brief, are that the petitioner is the Commissioner of Customs, Customs House, Chattogram a Government officer duly appointed by the National Board of Revenue. The petitioner exercises the statutory functions and powers conferred upon him under section 4 of the Customs Act, 1969 (the Act, 1969). Respondent No. 2, Maddhapara Granite Mining Company Limited is a state-owner enterprise operating under the authority and administrative control of Petrobangla (Bangladesh Oil, Gas and Mineral Corporation), Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. Respondent No. 2 is engaged in the extraction and production of hard rock from the Maddhapara Underground Hard Rock Mine situated in Dinajpur District.
4For the purpose of its operational requirements, respondent No. 2, in the ordinary course of business, opened a Letter of Credit No. 000001223010077 dated 16.03.2023 for the importation of 40,000.00 K.G. of Low Density Products Prilled Ammonium Nitrate from Korea. After arrival of the goods at Customs House, Chattogram, respondent No. 2, upon collecting the necessary shipping documents from its bank, submitted Bill of Entry No. 1062311 dated 09.07.2023 through its C&F Agent for assessment and release of the goods under H.S. Code No. 3102.30.00.
5Thereafter, pursuant to the Import Policy Order No. 2021–2024, the customs authority physically examined the imported goods and found that the H.S. Code declared by respondent No. 2 was incorrect and the imported goods ought to have been assessed under H.S. Code No. 2834.29.90. Accordingly, the customs authority held that such act of respondent No. 2 was in violation of section 32 of the Act, 1969, punishable under section 156(1) of the said Act.
6It is further stated that due to the sensitive and hazardous nature of the goods, their prolonged detention at the port posed serious safety and operational risks. Under such compelling circumstances, and having no effective alternative, respondent No. 2, through its C&F Agent, submitted an application before the petitioner for summary adjudication for the purpose of securing the immediate release of the goods.
7Upon receipt of the said application and after hearing respondent No. 2, the petitioner passed Adjudication Order No. 92 dated 11.07.2023
directing respondent No. 2 to pay additional customs duty and other charges amounting to Tk. 21,37,916.11 and thereby imposed a penalty of Tk. 43,00,000/- together with a redemption fine of Tk. 2,00,000/- under Table, Clause 14 of section 156(1) of the Act, 1969.
8Being compelled by the situation and in order to avoid serious operational disruption and safety hazards, respondent No. 2 secured release of the goods upon payment of the assessed customs duties and taxes, together with the penalty and redemption fine imposed by the adjudication order dated 11.07.2023.
9Being aggrieved thereby, respondent No. 2 preferred a customs appeal before the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”), being Customs Appeal No. (Cus)535/2023. Upon hearing the parties, the Tribunal, by its order dated 28.02.2024, allowed the appeal in part and set aside the penalty and redemption fine imposed by the petitioner.
10Challenging the said order passed by the Tribunal, the present petitioner filed the instant writ petition invoking the special original jurisdiction of this Court under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh and obtained the Rule along with an interim order of stay instead of preferring appeal as provided under the Act, 1969.
11Mr. Akhtar Farhad Zaman, the learned Deputy Attorney General appearing for the petitioners, submits that respondent No. 2, Maddhapara Granite Mining Company Limited, never admitted that its declared H.S. Code was a bona fide mistake. Rather, throughout the proceedings, respondent No. 2 consistently maintained that its classification was correct and neither sought rectification nor acknowledged any error. Despite such unequivocal stance, the Tribunal inexplicably held the incorrect declaration of the H.S. Code to be a bona fide mistake, thereby contradicting the respondent’s own position. Accordingly, Mr. Zaman submits that such determination is legally flawed, as it grants relief which was neither claimed nor admitted by respondent No. 2 and the order of the Tribunal is, therefore, internally inconsistent, rendered ex gratia, and devoid of any statutory justification.
12Mr. Zaman next submits that the Appellate Tribunal failed to consider the assessment of the import documents, nor did the Tribunal evaluate the findings of the assessment committee. Moreover, the Tribunal failed to consider the contemporaneous records relating to the pricing of similar goods.
13Mr. Zaman further submits that although the impugned order passed by the Tribunal is appealable under the Act, 1969, the petitioner could not prefer appeal within the stipulated time prescribed under section 196D of the Act, 1969, due to the necessity of obtaining permission from the concerned government authorities which occurred delay to prefer an
appeal. As such, the petitioner had no other efficacious alternative remedy except to invoke the special original jurisdiction of this Court under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh for the protection of Government revenue.
14On the other hand Mr. Mohammad Jamal Hossain, the learned Advocate appearing for respondent No. 2 submits that the instant writ petition is not maintainable, since the petitioner without preferring an appeal as required under section 196D of the Act, 1969 directly filed the writ petition and as such, the Rule is liable to be discharged as being not maintainable.
15Mr. Hossain referring the letter issued by the National Board of Revenue vide Nathi No. 08.01.0000.53.02.023.23/153 dated 02.04.2023 submits that in the said letter, the National Board of Revenue categorically stated in Clause “N” that if any item had previously been imported by declaring a particular H.S. Code or CPC and the authority subsequently changed the H.S. Code, such change should not be treated as misdeclaration. In view of the above, he submits that the Tribunal, upon considering the said clause of the NBR’s letter, passed the impugned order, and therefore there is no illegality in the impugned order.
16We have heard the learned Deputy Attorney General appearing for the petitioner and the learned Advocate appearing for respondent No. 2, have perused the writ petition, the relevant materials on record, and the annexures appended thereto and consulted the relevant provision of law.
17It, however appears from the record that, respondent No. 2 had earlier released the identical goods through the same Customs House under several Bills of Entry, namely Bill of Entry Nos. C-1715479 dated 15.10.2022 and C-1069799 dated 15.06.2022, by declaring H.S. Code No. 3102.30.00 and the customs authority assessed and released the goods under the said H.S. Code.
18It further appears from the impugned order that considering the Clause “N” of the NBR’s letter dated 02.04.2023, the Tribunal partly allowed the appeal. The Clause “N” is quoted below for ready reference;
19“(N)-Bjc¡¢eL«a fZÉ ®L¡−e¡ HL¢V L¡ØVj q¡Ep ®øne La«ÑL ®L¡−e¡ H.S.
20Code ¢Lwh¡ CPC BJa¡u öó¡uef§hÑL M¡m¡p flha£Ñ−a Eš² HLC fZÉ HLC
21h¡ ¢iæ L¡ØVj q¡Ep/®ØVn−el j¡dÉ−j Bjc¡¢el ®r−œ k¢c C−a¡f§−hÑ Ae¤−j¡¢ca
22H.S. Code ¢Lwh¡ CPC p¢WL eu j−jÑ L¡ØVj q¡E−pl H−pp−j¾V L¢j¢V
23¢Lwh¡ S¡a£u l¡Sü ®h¡−XÑl ®nËZ£¢heÉ¡p L¢j¢V La«ÑL ¢pÜ¡¿¹ Nªq£a qu Hhw/h¡
24f§−hÑl Ae¤−j¡¢ca H.S. Code ¢Lwh¡ CPC f¢lhaÑe Ll¡ qu a¡q−m a¡ ¢jbÉ¡
25®O¡oZ¡ ¢q−p−h ¢h−h¢Qa q−he¡z Partial Shipment p¤¢hd¡k¤š² GZf−œl
26®r−œJ H ¢hd¡e fË−k¡SÉ q−hz
27cg¡ (O)(L), (M) J (N) ®j¡a¡−hL L¡ØVjp La«ÑL ¢el¦¢fa h¡ Ae¤−j¡¢ca H.S.
28Code ¢Lwh¡ CPC hÉhq¡l e¡ L−l HLC Bjc¡¢eL¡lL La«ÑL HLC S¡a£u fZÉ
29i¤m H.S.Code ¢Lwh¡ CPC ®O¡oZ¡f§hÑL Bjc¡¢e Ll−m a¡ L¡øjp BC−el
3032 d¡l¡ ®j¡a¡−hL ¢jbÉ¡ ®O¡oZ¡ ¢q−p−h NZÉ q−h Hhw eÉ¡u ¢eZÑue fË−k¡SÉ
31q−hz”
32The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part holding that;
33“Aœ / /
l−u−R ! " # .# $ ! %&' য
) * " + i¤m ¢hd¡u S¡a£u l¡Sü ®h¡−XÑl Ef−l¡š²
A¡−c−nl Ae¤−µRc-N Hl ¢hd¡e ®j¡a¡−hL ü£u ¢hQ¡¢lL fБ¡ (Judicious Mind)
"&- & – . / 0% য – & '। ) 2
3! 3! ! # .# $য য % !
45 & The Customs Act, 1969 # Section-156 (1) # Table
# Clause-14 6) ¢pÜ¡¿¹ য য %& 7
।”
34In view of the above findings of the Tribunal, we do not find any illegality in the impugned order. However, it is settled principle of law that when any question of maintainability is raised by any party in a writ petition, the first duty of the Court is to examine whether the said writ petition is maintainable or not.
35In this regard, it appears from section 196D of the Act, 1969 that a specific provision has been inserted for filing an appeal before the High Court Division. The relevant provision is quoted below for ready reference;
“196D Appeal to the High Court Division- The Commissioner
of Customs or the other party may, within ninety days of the
date upon which he is served with notice of an order under
section 196B, by an application, prefer an appeal to the High
Court Division against such order”
36On consideration of the above provision, it is evident that any order passed by the Tribunal under section 196B of the Act, 1969 is an appealable order under the section 196D of the Act, 1969.
37In the instant case, the petitioner has not advanced any argument to show that the impugned order passed by the Tribunal violated any
fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution or it was passed in malafide, or in colorable exercise of power or without jurisdiction.
38Having considered the above facts and circumstances of the case together with the finding and observations made hereinabove, we are of the view that the instant writ petition is not maintainable.
39Accordingly, the Rule is discharged as being not maintainable.
40There will be no order as to costs.
41Communicate the order at once. Dihider Masum Kabir, J:
I agree.
42Md. Mashud sikeder-A.B.O.
Related summaries.
From the record to your case.
Our advocates appear before both divisions of the Supreme Court. These are the practice areas that handle matters like this one.
- Supreme Court practice in BangladeshSlips, mentioning, cause lists and appearances→
- Case JourneysHow a case moves through the courts, step by step→
- Limitation and appeal deadline calculatorKnow your last day to file→
- Curative petitions in BangladeshFinality, article 104 and the case for reform→
- Constitution guideEvery article and amendment, animated→
- Bangladesh legal glossaryBangla and English legal terms, explained→











